Gents, have been fishing the Bay all my life and I have to say a small lightly weighted SP stick bait (squidgy, gulp or similar) will out fish any metal 10 to 1.
The problem with metals is that they need to be retrieved fast. Most times they will only get hit if cast in the same line as the feeding school, and retrieved back in the same line as the fleeing baitfish. This takes a lot more thought in the approach with the boat...
With a lightly weighted SP, the degree of leniency is increased, and successful approaches can be made from different angles. This is due to the SP not really needing a retrieve to get hit - I have lost count the number of times the lure gets smashed almost immediately after the cast, without even a turn of the handle!
Other deadly lures for this style of fishing are the slider topwater lures. There are a few around designed for american bass by Japan houses such as megabass, but some australian lures are starting to show up (squidgy / bushy for eg). These lures again dont need a fast retrieve so can be cast in to the school from most angles and twitched on the surface, imitating a dying baitfish.
We have also noticed that when using these lures the precise "match the hatch" theory applies, but to a lesser degree. I recall times when I was left only with a 6" Sluggo, rigged on a wormhook, as I ran out of all other ~5cm options and still caught fish...
Guess its a matter of getting out there and trying different techniques
Tight lines!