This is part of a email from a very respected charter boat operator,that clearly is not happy with the decision.
The whole argument for the new points score system is based around giving the fish an even and sporting chance for their life. Letting the skill of the angler fight the fish. This will be achieved by giving MORE points to someone who "Tags & Releases" a fish on lighter line. So they can win a trophy!1. There is no benefit for the fish in this new system.2. Longer fighting times (enviro groups say "Torture Time") are not good for the fish. 3. How do you police the line class at the weigh station?? just because a boat uses heavier line doesn't necessarily mean they are fishing heavier drag. Show me an angler who can fish 80lb or 130lb as a true 80 or 130! yet alone fishing lighter line.Let’s give the fish a real go;4. If you want to give the fish a sporting chance then why not turn off your engines when you hook-up? Turn off your sonar, turn off your sounder, turn off your GPS, turn off your radio, radar, cell phone, live well, clickers/ratchets, electric teaser reels, sat phone, laptops, hard drives, marlin magnets and satellite sea surface temp printers. Stop paying crews to catch bait, rig baits, tease fish, tag /gaff fish for you. Make the angler do it. I
know many anglers among you all that can do it any way! And yes it’s bloody great to see. But does it matter as I always thought of fishing as a team sport any way.5. Lets ban reverse gear.6. All boats with a tower are banned.7. All professional crews are to be blindfolded.8. All boats to be cut down to 8 meters.9. All tackle (which you will now need plenty of) will be sold to you by tournament sponsors and club officials.10. If these rules don’t suit then change them all until they suit you best. Move the posts.Welfare of the fish hey? Let the live baiting continue! This new system will in fact play directly into the hands of the professional/seasoned captains and crews. Yes that’s me and my peers.WHY then do you ask that I am so opposed to this new system??I am opposed as it places personal gain, greed above the welfare of the fish, the moral ethic of the sport and the membership base of ALL clubs. As usual it’s all about winning a piece of timber.